Manufacturing doesn't trust a gage until it's proven repeatable and reproducible. This post introduces Reasoning R&R™, which applies that discipline to AI: does an evaluation match a known correct answer, does it repeat under the same conditions, and do different reviewers land in the same place. Running the framework on MAD-Ai's own 8D grading workflow surfaced 2,370 grading decisions, 93.2% repeatability, and 99% reproducibility between reviewers, plus twelve rubric criteri